Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 | Features | Specs | Price | Comparison 2020

Last updated:

Yesterday, Xiaomi Mi Band 5 hit the Chinese market for an affordable price of only 189 yuan ($26). So here we are comparing the best budget-friendly health wearables China has to offer, including Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5.  So, we will be comparing the features, the specs, and the price of all three bands and see which one’s the winner.

So, let’s dive into this Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 comparison:

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 – Which One Should You Select?

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 – Specs Sheet Comparison

Product Xiaomi Mi Band 5 Xiaomi Mi Band 4 Honor Band 5
Dimensions 47.2 x 18.5 x 12.4mm 21.6 x 10.8 x 9.66mm 43 × 17.2 × 11.5 mm
Weight 25 g 22.1 g 22.7 g
Material Plastic + Glass Plastic + Glass Plastic + Glass
Shape Elliptical Elliptical Rectangular
Strap Material Silicon Silicon Silicon
Customizable Yes, fully Yes, fully Yes, somewhat
Buckle Push-button Push-button Tang
Screen Type Color AMOLED Color AMOLED Color AMOLED
Screen Size 1.1″ 0.95″ 0.95″
Resolution 126 x 294 pixels 120 x 240 pixels 120 x 240 pixels
Brightness 450 nits 450 nits 400 nits
Battery capacity 125mAh 125mAh 100mAh
Battery life up to 20 days (14+ days advertised) up to 20 days up to 14 days
Charging time 2 hours 2 hours 1 hour
Charging Type Dock, Magnetic Dock, Pin Dock, Pin
Sports Mode 11 6 9
App Mi Fit Mi Fit Huawei Health
Price 189 Yuan (26 USD) 149 Yuan (21 USD) 189 Yuan (26 USD)

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 – Price Comparison

Starting the Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 comparison with the pricing. We have Xiaomi Mi Band 4 as the cheapest health wearable among these three. Xiaomi Mi Band 4 price was around 169 yuan ($24), however, after the release of Mi Band 5, the company dropped the price to 149 yuan ($21). However, if you are in search of the cheapest Chinese health wearable it is Redmi band which is not included in this comparison.

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 has a price tag of 189 yuan ($26) and is the most expensive one among the three.

Honor Band 5 is priced the same as the Xiaomi Mi Band 5 which is 189 yuan ($26). 

Now considering the price, we have Xiaomi Mi Band 4 as the cheapest one here thanks to the price drop. Yet, Honor Band 5 has the best price-to-performance ratio because of accurate readings than the Mi Band 4. Moreover, it also has all-day sleep monitoring and SPO2 level monitoring feature which is missing in Mi Band 4. As for the Mi Band 5, it does have slightly better readings than the Honor Band 5, and all-day sleep monitoring (including naps) when compared to Mi Band 4, however, the mentioned feature (SPO2) is still missing.

Winner: Xiaomi Mi Band 4 (in terms of pricing)

Winner: Honor Band 5 (in terms of price-to-performance ratio)

Product Xiaomi Mi Band 5 Xiaomi Mi Band 4 Honor Band 5
Price in Yuan (China) 189 yuan 149 yuan 189 yuan
Price in USD (USA/America) 26 USD 21 USD 26 USD
Price in Euro (UK) 24 euro 24 euro 24 euro
Price in INR (India) Rs.2044 Rs.2044 Rs.2044

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 – Design Comparison

Product Xiaomi Mi Band 5 Xiaomi Mi Band 4 Honor Band 5
Dimensions 47.2 x 18.5 x 12.4mm 21.6 x 10.8 x 9.66mm 43 × 17.2 × 11.5 mm
Weight 25 g 22.1 g 22.7 g
Material Plastic + Glass Plastic + Glass Plastic + Glass
Shape Elliptical Elliptical Rectangular

Moving to the design section of the comparison, there’s no major difference in terms of design in the Xiaomi Mi Band 5 and Xiaomi Mi Band 4. It’s still the same iconic elliptical (capsule) shape but slightly bigger in size in the Mi Band 5. Moreover, the circular touch button has been replaced with an arc-style touch button. That’s all!

At the bottom, we have the PPG sensor and the charging terminals. It should be noticed that Xiaomi hasn’t changed the location of the charging terminals for the Mi Band 5, but moved from a dock type charger to a much easy to use the magnetic charger. Now one can charge the band without removing it from the strap and avoid the loosing of the strap over time. Finally, one of the major problems of the Mi Band series resolved.

Images of Mi Band 5:

Images of Mi Band 4:

Meanwhile, Honor Band 5 is similar to its ancestor (Honor Band 4) and the newly released Redmi Band. It’s a classic rectangular design, slightly curved screen to fit well on the wrist. On the front, there’s the large white-colored circular button. It’s almost 2x the size of the circular button on the Mi Band 4, but much prominent. As for the charging, it doesn’t have the magnetic charging but the charger can be attached to the bottom terminals without removing the main chassis.

Images of Honor Band 5 (credit: Trusted Reviews):

So, I do prefer the Mi Band series in terms of design. They look much cooler and has a unique and minimalistic approach in terms of design. The large circle on the Honor band is annoying, plus, the design is somewhat common among Chinese smartwatches. However, everyone has a different taste. Moreover, cheers for the magnetic charging in Mi Band 5.

Winner: Xiaomi Band 5

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 – Strap Comparison

Product Xiaomi Mi Band 5 Xiaomi Mi Band 4 Honor Band 5
Strap Material Silicon Silicon Silicon
Customizable Yes, somewhat Yes, fully Yes, fully
Buckle  Push-button Tang Tang

All their devices have food-grade silicon made strap. The Mi Band 4 and 5 have a unique push-button buckle that looks nice and saves some time while wearing. However, this also brings problems like the buckle loosening over time and even coming out.

Moreover, I have replaced my Mi Band 4’s strap two times now in a year, just because of the ring hole of the strap breaking as well as the buckle coming out. The grip hasn’t been like it uses to. The straps are cheap and easily available in different designs. The customization thing is one of the reasons why I love this series and buy it even though I miss some features. I even wrote an article on top 10 Xiaomi Mi Band 4 straps and accessories.

Honor Band 5 buckle design is the traditional tang type but much better when it comes to locking it. It doesn’t come out or loosens over time which adds a plus to the durability.

 Winner: Honor Band 5 (in terms of durability)

Winner: Xiaomi Mi Band 4 and 5 (in terms of customization)

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 – Screen & Display Comparison

All of them have a color AMOLED display. The screen size is 0.95-inch with a resolution of 120 x 240 pixels (282 PPI) both in Xiaomi Mi Band 4 and Honor Band 5. In terms of brightness, Xiaomi Mi Band 4  has 450 nits brightness, while the Honor Band 5 has 400 nits of brightness. This makes Xiaomi Mi Band 4 brighter and more visible in sunlight.

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 has a much larger 1.1″ AMOLED display with a resolution of 126 x 294 resolution, 450 nits brightness.

All three have tempered glass for scratch protection. However, Xiaomi Mi Band 4 and 5 improve aesthetics by using the 2.5D glass arc which isn’t present in Honor Band 5.

Since Xiaomi Mi Band 5 has a bigger display and 450 nits brightness, it’s the winner of this section.

Winner: Xiaomi Mi Band 5

Product Xiaomi Mi Band 5 Xiaomi Mi Band 4 Honor Band 5
Screen Type Color AMOLED Color AMOLED Color AMOLED
Screen Size 1.1″ 0.95″ 0.95″
Resolution 126 x 294 pixels 120 x 240 pixels 120 x 240 pixels
Brightness 450 nits 450 nits 400 nits

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 – Hardware & Performance

Xiaomi Mi Band 4 and 5 are equipped with a 6-axis motion sensor: 3-axis accelerometer + 3-axis gyroscope. The 3-axis accelerometer is responsible for sensing front, rear left, and right (three-dimensional space). Meanwhile, the three-axis gyroscope separate dynamic information that senses left and right tilt, front and rear tilt, and left and right swing. As for Honor Band 5, we also have the same 6-axis motion sensor.

All three bands have a PPG sensor for HR detection and support abnormal heart rate alerts. The accuracy with be discussed in the features and function section. Xiaomi mentions that the PPG sensor has been upgraded in Mi Band 5, making it 50% more accurate than the previous generation. This also means that it beats the Honor band 5 since Honor Band 5 and Mi Band 4 HR readings were almost similar.

All three bands have their special NFC version.

As for the algorithms which help in the accuracy of the measurements, we have Xiaomi Mi Band 5 with most updated algorithms, then comes Honor Band 5, and the last one is Xiaomi Mi Band 4.

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 has the most upgraded hardware

Winner: Xiaomi Mi Band 5

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 – Functions & Features

I have made a comparison table of the features to clearly illustrate what’s missing in each wearable.

Model Xiaomi Mi Band 5 Xiaomi Mi Band 4 Honor Band 5
Pedometer Yes Yes Yes
HR sensor Yes Yes Yes
HR alert Yes Yes Yes
Sleep tracker Yes (REM eye movement added, all-day tracking) Yes (night tracking only) Yes (all-day tracking)
Calories burned Yes Yes Yes
Distance measurement Yes Yes Yes
PAI vitality index Yes No No
Women Health Yes No No
Breathing training guidance Yes No No
Stress Level Test Yes No Yes
Blood Oxygen Monitoring No No Yes
Sedentary reminder Yes Yes Yes
Sports Modes 11 6 9
Payment options Yes, Alipay, UnionPay (in NFC version) Yes, Alipay (in NFC version) Yes, Alipay (in NFC version)
Alarm Yes Yes Yes
App notification Yes Yes Yes
Weather Yes Yes Yes
Music Player Yes Yes No
Stopwatch Yes Yes Yes
Timer Yes Yes Yes
Find Device Yes Yes Yes
Remote Camera Control Yes No Yes
Dynamic Dial Yes No No
DND Yes Yes Yes

One thing found in Honor Band 5 is that the user can customize the functions of the band, making it either a health watch only, a smartwatch only, or both. Xiaomi Mi Band series do have this as well but one can turn only specific functions like push notification, sedentary reminder etc.

In terms of accuracy, the pedometer of Honor Band 5 is the most accurate. It’s not perfect, but way better than Mi Band 4 and 5 which show false steps and distance especially while riding a bike.

As for the Heart rate monitoring, Xiaomi Mi Band 5 has the most accurate HR readings thanks to the upgraded PPG sensor. The officials say that the accuracy of irregular heart rate monitoring is increased by up to 50%. Then we have the Honor Band 5 which has better HR accuracy than Mi Band 4.

Concerning the sleep tracker, Xiaomi Mi Band 5 has the most accurate readings improved by 40% compared to the Mi Band 4, thanks to the newly added REM feature. Another important update we need to know is that Xiaomi Mi Band 5 has all-day (nap + sleep) monitoring which was missing in Xiaomi Mi Band 4.

Clock faces

Xiaomi Mi Band 4 has around 77 dials/clock faces. And the new Mi Band 5 has 100 clock faces by default including the newly added dynamic ones and analog ones as well. The third-party dial apps are enormous in numbers.

In comparison, Honor band 5 doesn’t have that much clock faces and have fewer clock faces third-party apps.

Sports Modes Comparison

One of the essential features of the wearables is the sports mode. All three have multiple sports modes. Xiaomi Mi Band 5 has the most ones numbering around 11 modes including (yoga, elliptical machine, rowing machine, skipping rope, indoor climb, swimming, freestyle, outdoor running, treadmill, cycling, walking)

Mi Band 4 has the least ones numbering 6 features (swimming, freestyle, outdoor running, treadmill, cycling, walking).

Honor Band 5 comes at second with 9 modes (indoor walking, rowing, elliptical, swimming, freestyle, outdoor running, treadmill, cycling, walking)

We might not have the SPO2 meter in Mi Band 5 with us, but we do have 5 additional features when compared to the Honor Band 5 and 3 more sports modes as well. The HR readings and sleep readers are the most accurate ones among the three with the addition of the REM feature. False-positive may occur as they use to in Mi Band 4 but that’s fine. This is why we have selected the winner of this section to be Xiaomi Mi Band 5.

Winner: Xiaomi Mi Band 5

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 – App Comparison

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 and 4 use the Mi Fit App (4.2 ratings), meanwhile, the Honor Band 5 uses Huawei Health (3.2 ratings). So we have the Mi Fit vs Huawei Health comparison here. Each app is unique in its own way. The UI also resembles each other in most parts. However, I do love the sleep tracker of Huawei Health which has slightly more details to it and the day-time sleeping. The HR tracker on Mi Fit is much detailed than Huawei Health.

Screenshots of the latest version of Mi Fit:

Screenshot of the latest version of Huawei Health:

Honor band 5

However, Mi Health has way too few bugs and connectivity issues compared to the Huawei Health app. Users have reported how they are not able to connect to their bands in the latest versions, and firmware errors also exist. These are much less for Mi Fit and Mi Band series.

Huawei Health reviews
Recent reviews on Huawei Health

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 – Battery Comparison

Product Xiaomi Mi Band 5 Xiaomi Mi Band 4 Honor Band 5
Battery capacity 125mAh 125mAh 100mAh
Battery life up to 20 days (14+ days advertised) up to 20 days up to 14 days
Charging time 2 hours 2 hours 1 hour
Charging Type Dock, Magnetic Dock, Pin Dock, Pin

Among the three, Xiaomi Mi Band 5 and Mi Band 4 have the same battery life which is up to 20 days on a single charge. The battery capacity is also the same which is 125mAh. The battery charges in 2 hours from 0% to 100%. The magnetic charging feature added is incredible.

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 Magnetic Charge

Honor Band 4 has a much lesser battery capacity and the other two, which is 100mAh, however, it also promises battery life up to 14 days. The battery charges in 1 hour from 0% to 100%.

Honor Band 5 charger
Honor band 5 charging dock
Mi Band 4
Mi Band 4 charging dock

In this section of Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 comparison, there’s no winner. This is because the battery life of all three bands depends on the frequency of usage, the HR interval set, the brightness setting and other features activated. With almost most of the extra features turned off and the HR interval set at 30 minutes, I was able to get 16 days of battery life on the Mi Band 4.

Winner: None (Tie)

The Verdict

It’s good to see that the one-year-old Honor Band 5 has managed to compete against the newly released Mi Band 5. Xiaomi Mi Band 5 does have better readings in terms of HR and sleep tracking, more sports modes, 5 new additional features, and magnetic charging that are missing in Honor Band 5 and Mi Band 4. The price difference it’s that much as all three are ranging between $20 to $30 which is ultra-cheap. However, all these features in Mi Band 5 do come at a sacrifice which is no blood oxygen monitoring, and the same false-positive errors in steps and distance.

Xiaomi Mi Band 5 (5 points) | Xiaomi Mi Band 4 ( 2 points) | Honor Band 5 (2 points)

Collecting points from each section of the Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 comparison, we have Xiaomi Mi Band 5 as the ultimate winner.

Overall Winner: Xiaomi Mi Band 5

Also Read:

You can grab the bands from here for the best prices:

You can grab Xiaomi Mi Band 5 for $28.99 on Aliexpress which is the best price yet on the internet. Here’s the link to the store when in the button below:

Do you know? Xiaomi Mi Band 5 Chinese version (CN) and Global version are almost the same. You get Alipay in Chinese version, while it’s not available in global version. Moreover, only the box labeling and user guide is in Chinese for the CN version. The default language of the band is in Chinese, however, you can change it automatically once you connect with Mi Fit App. Oh and one more thing Mi Band 5 Chinese version is also cheaper ($3 to $5) than the global verison.

 

We hope you loved our Xiaomi Mi Band 5 vs Xiaomi Mi Band 4 vs Honor Band 5 comparison. Did we miss anything? Let us know in the comments.

More Stories
vivo-origin-os-review-d
Vivo Origin OS Review – List of Devices To Get Update